Best Christmas Choral Music Guide

This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

The first notes of a familiar carol, sung in rich harmony, can instantly transport us. It’s a sound that defines the holiday season—a blend of reverence, joy, and shared tradition that echoes through concert halls, churches, and town squares. For choir directors, selecting the right Christmas music is one of the most important and rewarding tasks of the year. It’s about more than just finding notes on a page; it’s about crafting an experience, telling a story, and connecting with an audience on a deeply emotional level.

But where do you even begin? The world of Christmas choral music is vast, spanning centuries of history, a multitude of styles, and pieces suited for every imaginable skill level. From the soaring polyphony of the Renaissance to the lush harmonies of the 21st century, the repertoire is as rich as it is intimidating.

A great Christmas program isn’t just a collection of songs; it’s a carefully curated journey that balances the familiar with the fresh, the sacred with the secular, and the technically challenging with the simply beautiful.

This guide is designed to be your definitive resource for navigating that journey. We’ll explore the cornerstones of the Christmas choral tradition, uncover hidden gems, and provide practical advice for building a program that will resonate with your singers and your audience. Whether you’re directing a seasoned cathedral choir, a small community ensemble, or a brand-new school group, you’ll find the insights and inspiration needed to make this holiday season your most memorable one yet. We’ll delve into the historical roots of these beloved pieces, break down their musical character, and offer a curated selection of the very best works for your choir to bring to life.

The Foundation: Understanding the Christmas Choral Tradition

Before we dive into specific pieces, it’s crucial to understand the historical and cultural soil from which this music grew. The practice of singing to celebrate the nativity dates back to the early days of the Christian church, but what we recognize today as Christmas choral music truly began to take shape in the Middle Ages and blossomed during the Renaissance.

Initially, these were simple, monophonic chants. But as musical composition evolved, so did the music of Christmas. The development of polyphony—the interweaving of multiple independent melodic lines—allowed composers to create works of breathtaking complexity and beauty. This was the era of composers like Josquin des Prez and Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina, who crafted motets for the Christmas season that were both spiritually profound and technically masterful.

The Reformation played a pivotal role in this evolution. Martin Luther, a musician himself, believed congregational singing was essential to worship. This led to the creation of the chorale—a simple, hymn-like tune that the entire congregation could sing. Composers like Michael Praetorius and, later, Johann Sebastian Bach, took these simple chorales and transformed them into elaborate, multi-movement works for choir and orchestra, known as cantatas. Bach’s Christmas Oratorio remains one of the towering achievements of Western music, a testament to the power of the chorale as a foundation for sacred composition.

The Victorian era in 19th-century England marked another significant turning point. This period saw a revival of interest in traditional carols, many of which had been passed down through oral tradition for centuries. Collections like Carols for Choirs, first published in the 20th century by David Willcocks and John Rutter, standardized many of these tunes and arranged them in the lush, four-part harmony that has become synonymous with the sound of Christmas. It’s this tradition that gave us the beloved descants and soaring soprano lines that define so many classic carols today.

Understanding this history isn’t just an academic exercise. It informs how we interpret and perform these pieces. When you program a Renaissance motet alongside a Victorian carol, you’re creating a dialogue across centuries, showcasing the incredible diversity and enduring power of this musical tradition.

Building Your Program: The Art of Selection

A successful Christmas concert is built on a foundation of thoughtful programming. The goal is to create a balanced and engaging experience for both the performers and the audience. This means considering a variety of factors, from the skill level of your choir to the theme of your concert.

Know Your Choir: Assessing Skill and Voicing

The most important factor in selecting repertoire is the ability of your singers. Be honest and realistic about their strengths and weaknesses.

SATB (Soprano, Alto, Tenor, Bass): This is the standard four-part voicing for mixed choirs and offers the widest range of available repertoire. However, a true four-part division requires a solid tenor section and basses who can handle a low range, which can be a challenge for many amateur choirs.
SAB (Soprano, Alto, Baritone): This is an excellent option for choirs with few or no tenors. The baritone part is written to accommodate both tenors and basses, making it much more accessible. Many popular SATB arrangements are also available in SAB versions.
Two-Part (SA or TB): Ideal for children’s choirs, smaller women’s or men’s ensembles, or choirs just starting out. The simplicity of two-part harmony can be incredibly beautiful and allows for a strong focus on blend, tone, and musicality.
Unison: Never underestimate the power of a well-sung unison melody. It’s a fantastic way to begin or end a concert, and it allows the entire choir to focus on creating a single, unified sound. Many carols are incredibly effective when sung in unison, perhaps with a piano or organ accompaniment that provides the harmonic interest.

Difficulty Levels: Be sure to select a mix of pieces that challenge your choir without overwhelming them. A good program will include a few more challenging works that stretch their abilities, balanced by several pieces that they can learn relatively quickly and sing with confidence. This builds morale and ensures a polished final performance.

Crafting a Narrative: Thematic Programming

Instead of simply presenting a random assortment of songs, consider creating a program with a clear thematic arc. This gives the concert a sense of purpose and cohesion.

Lessons and Carols: Based on the traditional service from King’s College, Cambridge, this format alternates scripture readings with choral music. It tells the Christmas story in a powerful and moving way, from the prophecy of Christ’s birth to the visit of the Magi.
A Journey Through Time: Program your concert chronologically, starting with medieval chants and moving through Renaissance motets, Baroque cantatas, Victorian carols, and contemporary compositions. This is a wonderful way to educate your audience about the history of Christmas music.
Christmas Around the World: Showcase the diversity of holiday traditions by programming music from different countries and cultures. Include a Spanish villancico, a German chorale, a French noël, and perhaps a spiritual or a piece from the African diaspora.
A Thematic Focus: You could also build a program around a single theme, such as “light,” “peace,” or “joy.” Select pieces whose texts and moods reflect this central idea.

The Repertoire: A Curated Guide to the Best Christmas Choral Pieces

Here is a selection of some of the finest Christmas choral music, organized by period and style. This is by no means an exhaustive list, but it represents a core repertoire that every choir director should know.

The Renaissance and Baroque: Pillars of the Tradition

This era gave us some of the most sublime and spiritually profound music ever written. While it can be challenging, the rewards are immense.

“O Magnum Mysterium” – Morten Lauridsen

While composed in 1994, Lauridsen’s setting of this ancient text is deeply rooted in the Renaissance tradition of polyphony. It has become one of the most performed and beloved choral works of the modern era, and for good reason. The piece is a masterclass in managing dissonance and release, creating a sense of profound awe and wonder. The slowly unfolding harmonies and luminous textures perfectly capture the mystery of the nativity.

Voicing: SATB (with divisi)
Difficulty: Advanced
Why it’s a must: It’s a modern classic that feels timeless. It will challenge your choir’s intonation and breath control, but the emotional payoff is unparalleled.

“Hodie Christus Natus Est” – Jan Pieterszoon Sweelinck

For a joyful and energetic concert opener, look no further than Sweelinck’s setting of this Christmas Day antiphon. This piece is a brilliant example of late Renaissance counterpoint, with cascading melodic lines and vibrant, dance-like rhythms. The call-and-response between different sections of the choir creates a thrilling sense of celebration.

Voicing: SSATB
Difficulty: Intermediate to Advanced
Why it’s a must: It’s pure, unadulterated joy. The rhythmic vitality is infectious, and it’s a fantastic way to showcase your choir’s agility and energy.

“For Unto Us a Child Is Born” from Messiah – George Frideric Handel

No Christmas concert is truly complete without something from Handel’s Messiah. While the entire oratorio is a monumental undertaking, this particular chorus is a standalone masterpiece. The brilliant choral writing, with its famous melismatic passages on the word “born,” is the epitome of Baroque splendor.

Voicing: SATB
Difficulty: Intermediate to Advanced
Why it’s a must: It’s the quintessential sound of Christmas triumph. The technical demands are significant, but mastering this piece is a rite of passage for any serious choir.

“In Dulci Jubilo” – arr. Michael Praetorius

This arrangement of the beloved German carol is a perfect example of early Baroque charm. Praetorius sets the familiar tune in a variety of ways, from a simple four-part chorale to a more complex, imitative texture. His setting for double choir is particularly effective, creating a rich and festive sound.

Voicing: SATB (or double choir)
Difficulty: Intermediate
Why it’s a must: It’s a joyful and accessible entry point into the world of early Baroque music. It’s festive, fun to sing, and a guaranteed audience-pleaser.

The Victorian Era and Early 20th Century: The Birth of the Modern Carol

This period cemented the “traditional” sound of Christmas that we know and love today. The arrangements from this era are lush, romantic, and deeply nostalgic.

The Carols for Choirs Collection – arr. David Willcocks & John Rutter

It’s impossible to overstate the influence of this collection. The arrangements by Sir David Willcocks and John Rutter have become the definitive versions of many beloved carols. Their settings are characterized by rich harmonies, elegant voice leading, and, most famously, soaring soprano descants.

Key Pieces to Consider:
- “O Come, All Ye Faithful” (arr. Willcocks): The grand, organ-driven arrangement with its iconic descant is the gold standard.
- “Hark! The Herald Angels Sing” (arr. Willcocks): Another powerhouse arrangement that has become inseparable from the carol itself.
- “The First Nowell” (arr. Willcocks): A masterclass in building excitement, with each verse adding a new layer of texture and harmony.
- “Sussex Carol” (arr. Willcocks): A joyful, dance-like carol that is incredibly fun to sing.
Voicing: SATB (many available in SAB and two-part)
Difficulty: Easy to Intermediate
Why it’s a must: This is the bedrock of the traditional Christmas concert. These arrangements are impeccably crafted, and they are the sound that most people associate with Christmas.

“A Ceremony of Carols” – Benjamin Britten

Composed during World War II, this extended work for treble voices and harp is one of the most unique and atmospheric pieces in the Christmas repertoire. Britten sets medieval texts with a stark, modern sensibility. The use of the harp creates a magical, otherworldly sound, and the plainchant “Hodie Christus Natus Est” that frames the work gives it a powerful sense of ritual.

Voicing: SSA (or SA with optional soloists) and Harp
Difficulty: Intermediate to Advanced
Why it’s a must: It’s utterly original and breathtakingly beautiful. If you have a strong treble choir and access to a harpist, this piece will be the unforgettable centerpiece of your concert.

“Bethlehem Down” – Peter Warlock

This is a carol of quiet, haunting beauty. Warlock, whose real name was Philip Heseltine, wrote this piece with the poet Bruce Blunt to win a newspaper carol competition. The harmony is lush and chromatic, with a sense of melancholy that is unusual for a Christmas carol. It’s a moment of profound and introspective beauty in any program.

Voicing: SATB
Difficulty: Intermediate
Why it’s a must: It offers a different emotional color. Amidst all the joy and celebration, this piece provides a moment of quiet contemplation and exquisite harmonic richness.

Contemporary Classics: The New Tradition

In the latter half of the 20th century and into the 21st, composers have continued to enrich the Christmas repertoire with works that are both innovative and deeply rooted in tradition.

John Rutter: The Modern Master

No contemporary composer is more associated with Christmas choral music than John Rutter. His carols are beloved by choirs and audiences worldwide for their beautiful melodies, lush harmonies, and expert craftsmanship.

Key Pieces to Consider:
- “Shepherd’s Pipe Carol”: A joyful and energetic carol with a wonderfully catchy melody and a bubbling piano accompaniment.
- “What Sweeter Music”: A stunningly beautiful and lyrical piece. The warm, rich harmonies are classic Rutter, and it’s a showcase for your choir’s ability to sing with a beautiful, blended tone.
- “Candlelight Carol”: A gentle, lullaby-like carol with a simple, memorable melody. It’s incredibly effective and accessible for choirs of all levels.
- “Star Carol”: A bright, celebratory carol that makes for a fantastic concert opener or closer.
Voicing: Mostly SATB, but many are available in other voicings.
Difficulty: Easy to Intermediate
Why he’s a must: Rutter’s music is the definition of “audience-pleaser.” It’s beautifully written for the voice, emotionally direct, and impeccably crafted.

“The Lamb” – John Tavener

A masterpiece of 20th-century minimalism. Tavener’s setting of William Blake’s poem is deceptively simple. The piece uses homophonic textures and a technique called “isorhythm” to create a sense of timeless, mystical stillness. The dissonances are stark but resolve in moments of pure, transcendent beauty.

Voicing: SATB
Difficulty: Intermediate (requires excellent intonation and control)
Why it’s a must: It’s a moment of profound spiritual depth. The stillness and purity of this piece can be a powerful antidote to the commercial chaos of the season.

“Northern Lights” – Ola Gjeilo

Norwegian composer Ola Gjeilo has become one of the most popular choral composers of his generation. “Northern Lights” is a setting of a sacred text that uses the aurora borealis as a metaphor for divine beauty. The music is lush, cinematic, and deeply atmospheric, with shimmering cluster chords and soaring melodic lines.

Voicing: SATB
Difficulty: Intermediate to Advanced
Why it’s a must: It’s pure sonic beauty. This piece allows your choir to explore a rich and complex harmonic language and create a truly immersive sound world.

“There Is No Rose” – Z. Randall Stroope

Stroope’s setting of this medieval text is one of the most popular contemporary Christmas pieces, and for good reason. It’s dramatic, passionate, and incredibly well-written for the voice. The piece builds from a gentle, unison opening to a powerful, full-choir climax before fading away to a quiet, reflective close.

Voicing: SATB (with piano and optional oboe)
Difficulty: Intermediate
Why it’s a must: It has a powerful emotional arc. It’s a piece that tells a story, and it gives your choir a chance to showcase their dynamic range and expressive capabilities.

Beyond the Classics: Exploring Other Traditions

A truly memorable Christmas program will often include a few surprises. Stepping outside the standard Eurocentric repertoire can add wonderful color and variety to your concert.

Spirituals and Gospel

The African American spiritual tradition offers a wealth of powerful and deeply moving music for the Christmas season.

“Go, Tell It on the Mountain” (arr. John W. Work III or Howard Helvey): This joyful and exuberant spiritual is a Christmas staple. Look for an arrangement that captures the authentic rhythmic drive and call-and-response style of the tradition.
“Mary Had a Baby” (arr. William Dawson): A beautiful and tender spiritual that tells the story of the nativity with simplicity and grace. Dawson’s arrangement is a classic, full of rich harmonies and expressive depth.
“Behold the Star” (arr. William L. Dawson): A lesser-known but stunningly effective piece that builds to a powerful climax. It’s a fantastic processional or concert opener.

Music from Around the World

“Huron Carol” (arr. R. Vaughan Williams or others): Canada’s oldest Christmas carol, originally written in the Huron language. Its haunting, modal melody is incredibly atmospheric.
“Still, Still, Still” (arr. Norman Luboff): A beautiful Austrian carol arranged with lush, warm harmonies by the legendary Norman Luboff. It’s a perfect moment of quiet beauty.
“Riu, Riu, Chiu” (attr. Mateo Flecha the Elder): A lively and rhythmic Spanish villancico from the Renaissance. The percussive text and dance-like energy make it a fun and engaging piece for any choir.

Final Touches: Rehearsal and Performance

Once you’ve selected your repertoire, the real work begins. Here are a few tips for bringing the music to life.

Study the Text: Before you teach a single note, make sure your choir understands the meaning and context of the text. What is the story? What is the emotional core of the poem? This will inform every aspect of their singing, from phrasing to tone color.
Focus on the Fundamentals: Christmas music, with its often-familiar melodies, can sometimes lead to lazy singing. Insist on good posture, breath support, and beautiful tone from the very first rehearsal.
Pacing is Everything: Pay attention to the flow of your concert. Alternate fast and slow pieces, loud and soft, familiar and unfamiliar. Think of the concert as a single, cohesive emotional journey.
Don’t Forget the Audience: Consider including one or two carols for the audience to sing along with the choir. This is a wonderful way to create a sense of community and shared celebration. It breaks down the barrier between performers and listeners and reminds everyone what the season is all about.

The tradition of Christmas choral music is a precious gift, passed down through generations. It’s a living history, a shared language that connects us to the past and points us toward a future of hope and peace. As a choir director, you are a steward of this tradition. By choosing your music with care, rehearsing with intention, and performing with heart, you do more than just put on a concert. You create a space for wonder, for reflection, and for the kind of joy that can only be found when voices are raised together in song.